This quasi-debate was really a sort of two-on-one radio interview of non-theist Robert Manning by two incredibly overconfident theistics, including Pastor Gene Cook. This one starts out slow and slowly becomes ironical, then ludicrous, then hilarious. I’ve listened to it 2½ times now, going on three.
The credulity gap here is about as wide as you can get, with one side certain of nothing beyond cogito ergo sum and the other side claiming apodictic certainty of the finer points of their refined reformed theology. It would appear that presuppositionalism and hyperskepticism are more like oil and water than, say, vinegar and baking soda.
Turning presuppositionalism around, Manning the überskeptic hypothesizes about a deity which Pastor Cook can’t quite grok, because this hypothetical being does not reveal its true nature for a full 7,000 years rather than a mere 6,000 years after creating the planet. I know, right? The mind reels.
Money quote – “God is god and you’re a little piece of horse dung!”
(You'll never guess who said that :-)